top of page

the elephant's Den

Heroes or Villains? The Tale of Luigi Mangione and Daniel Penny

Writer's picture: The ElephantThe Elephant

Updated: Dec 11, 2024

In the court of public opinion, truth is not a requirement.


They say history repeats itself, but in the case of Luigi Mangione and Daniel Penny, history has clearly gone off its meds. These two men—one hailed as a savior, the other skewered as a villain—are at the heart of one of the most absurdly contradictory narratives the liberal left has ever spun. It’s a parody of modern media, where facts are optional, and heroes are chosen not by their actions but by their ideological utility.


Let’s dive into this madness.


Luigi Mangione: Murder for a Cause


Born into wealth, Luigi Mangione grew up in the lap of luxury, spoon-fed not just caviar but also a hearty dose of anti-capitalist ideology at his Ivy League university. (Because nothing says "fight the system" like a $300,000 education paid for by Daddy's gravy train.)


Luigi’s claim to fame? The cold-blooded assassination of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, a husband, father, and by all accounts, a man whose biggest crime was leading a health insurance company. But no, in the eyes of the liberal left, Thompson was a monster. Why? Because profit margins, of course.


Taylor Lorenz, now moonlighting as a Vox podcaster, gleefully admitted feeling “joy” at Thompson’s death—though she later downgraded her emotions to “maybe not joy, but certainly not empathy,” as if this clarification somehow made her sound less unhinged.


To the liberal elite, Luigi isn’t a murderer. He’s a martyr, a hero, a capitalist-slaying Robin Hood. Never mind that he premeditatedly killed a man in cold blood. Forget that his actions orphaned two children. No, Luigi is being lauded as the symbol of righteous vengeance, a modern-day Che Guevara (without the pesky guerrilla warfare).


And then there’s Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene, who warned that Luigi’s "activism" could spark a progressive crusade for socialized medicine. “I’ve been watching this unfold,” she said, “and I believe it’s the beginning of a political movement.” Luigi Mangione: poster boy for “Murder for Medicare.”


Daniel Penny: Defense Is a Dirty Word


Contrast Luigi with Daniel Penny, a man who dared to defend himself and others in a New York City subway from a violent attacker. Penny, a former Marine, found himself face-to-face with Jordan Neely, a man with 47 prior arrests, a history of violent assaults, and a rap sheet that reads like a crime anthology.


Penny acted in self-defense, assisted by two other men—one Black and one Hispanic. But the media has ignored these inconvenient details, opting instead to brand Penny a "racist murderer." Why? Because Penny is white, and Neely was Black. Case closed.


Never mind that Neely’s behavior posed a clear and present danger. Never mind that Penny’s actions potentially saved lives (not just white lives). In today’s world, self-defense is apparently a crime if it disrupts the liberal narrative.


Hank Newsome, a New York BLM leader, fanned the flames, calling for “Black vigilantes” to rise up in response to Penny’s acquittal. “How about we do the same when they attempt to oppress us?” he declared. Yes, because nothing says “justice” like encouraging more violence.


The Media Circus


Here’s where the real absurdity shines: the media’s portrayal of these two men.


Jordan Neely? He’s a misunderstood street performer, a creative soul who simply fell on hard times. Never mind the broken bones and trauma he previously inflicted on his victims. He’s the real victim here.


Brian Thompson? According to the liberal narrative, he’s the devil incarnate, a capitalist fat cat who personally denied healthcare to millions. Never mind that his "crimes" are entirely speculative. In the liberal fantasy, he might as well have been twirling his mustache while tying damsels to train tracks.


Luigi is painted as a saint, Penny as a monster. One is lauded for premeditated murder; the other vilified for protecting lives. It’s a masterclass in hypocrisy.


A Nation Divided


The tales of Luigi Mangione and Daniel Penny reveal a deep cultural divide in America. In one corner, we have a growing tolerance—nay, celebration—of violence, as long as it’s cloaked in progressive ideology. In the other, we see the demonization of those who uphold basic principles like self-defense and honor.


This isn’t justice. It’s a sick game of ideological favoritism, where the rules are written in crayon and the winners are determined by the media elites.


So, what’s next? Will a statute be made of Luigi Mangione like other heros like George Floyd? Will Daniel Penny become a cautionary tale for anyone who dares to protect themselves? In this upside-down world, anything seems possible.


The Real Heroes and Villains


At the end of the day, this isn’t about Luigi or Penny. It’s about the narratives we allow to shape our society. When murder becomes "activism" and self-defense becomes "racism," we’ve lost the plot.


Luigi Mangione isn’t a hero. Daniel Penny isn’t a villain. But in the theater of modern media, facts don’t matter. It’s all about the story—however absurd, however ludicrous, however dangerous it may be.


So, cue the laugh track. Or maybe the tears.


Disclaimer:


The content of this article is based on publicly available news and is intended for commentary purposes only. While it appears that law enforcement has identified Luigi Mangione as the prime suspect in a high-profile case, it is important to note that he is presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.


In contrast, Daniel Penny has been acquitted and found innocent by a jury of his peers, though New York’s Attorney General continues to pursue legal avenues that some critics view as an attempt to weaponize the legal system to further a divisive racial narrative.


Readers are encouraged to critically assess these cases and consider the broader societal implications.

13 views0 comments

Comentarios


bottom of page